Unpopular opinion? Maybe…probably
So, rope boy and I were talking the other day about racism. He was saying how the best way to combat racism isn’t to sweep it under the rug, but to talk about it openly. I totally agree with that. In white suburbia the most common thing to do is just pretend that it doesn’t exist, and we both agreed that the best way to combat that is by talking about it.
But, here’s the problem, at least for me. I’m white. I will never be allowed in a conversation about race because I’m white. I don’t get to have any space in the conversation. It doesn’t matter what I think, how educated about the topic I am, or anything else; I am white and am not allowed. How can I have a conversation about race if I’m not allowed? How can I talk about it if both sides (white culture and POC culture) don’t want me to talk about it?
I said that to him and he just shrugged. There isn’t really a good solution. If I talk about it with POC, then I’m whitesplaning, or erasing, or am generally entering a territory where I’m not wanted because historically I’ve done some fucked up shit (this is aside from the fact that I may not be educated/have the experience to understand everything that is being said to me, no matter how hard I try.) If I talk about it with other white people, then I’m making racism a big deal, or am making everyone uncomfortable, or (in extreme cases) am a race-traitor. So what am I supposed to do if I care and want to talk and learn about it?
There’s the idea that I should just shut-up and listen. Cool, I can do that. I want to hear about what’s going on with you and the problems you face so I can understand better. But if I start caring and want to get involved in activism or the discussion, I’m not allowed. The idea is that I’m supposed to let you solve it. Cool, I get it, and that’s fine too. Go for it, not gonna stop you.
If I talk about it with other white people, who may not be as aware or educated as I am, I’m met with defiance on that end too. I want them to see what’s going on and to care about it too! But because I’m talking about racism, a non-white problem, I get hushed up. Hell, I get hushed up in general about anything controversial while in white culture, but this is doubly true for racism. So, I can’t have a conversation about it with them. And besides which, POC don’t really want me talking to other white people because I’ll probably end up white-washing everything and white people will only care because it’s a white girl talking about it. On top of that, this is yet again a white person trying to solve their problems by making other white people aware. They can do that on their own, why don’t I just back the hell off?
I guess what I’m getting at is, though I’m not entitled to enter POC space, what am I supposed to do? If I care and am aware, am I supposed to just stay quiet and not do anything? How is that any better than being uninformed? Even if I educate myself about the issues, I’ll never really understand because I’ve never experienced it and I wont be allowed in the conversation, so what’s the point in educating myself about it? Why educate myself if all I’m going to do is sit in the corner, frustrated because I can’t say anything, all the while being hyper-aware of the fact that my mere existence is oppressive?
The whole this is, I don’t know what my role as a potential white ally is supposed to be. What am I supposed to do? And if I do nothing, then why am I bothering to educate myself and form opinions? I dunno…:/ I guess I don’t understand enough.